Ajit Pai: California net neutrality law is “illegal” – Boing Boing (blog)

[view original post]

California’s best-in-America Net Neutrality law goes a long way to restoring the protections that Trump’s FCC Chairman Ajit Pai destroyed when he unilaterally and illegally repealed the FCC’s national Net Neutrality rules.

Pai has now said that California’s law is illegal, because only the federal government can regulate telcos.

During the Obama years, when Pai was a mere FCC commissioner, he argued that states had the right to overrule federal telcoms rules. But he was arguing in favor of states’ rights to overrule federal regulations that said states couldn’t stop cities from building municipal internet services that competed with the telcos that Pai formerly served in an executive capacity.

The California rules are actually quite similar to those that used to be enforced by the FCC before Pai led a vote to kill the rules. The California bill bans blocking, throttling, and paid prioritization, just like the federal rules did. California’s bill goes beyond the old FCC rules by also banning paid data-cap exemptions (“zero-rating”).

Pai said the California bill’s restriction on zero-rating will “prevent Californian consumers from buying many free-data plans,” including ones that “allow consumers to stream video, music, and the like exempt from any data limits.”

The California bill would prevent ISPs from demanding payments from websites or online services in exchange for data cap exemptions. California lawmakers decided to ban paid data-cap exemptions because they could prioritize some services over others and give ISPs an incentive to impose lower data limits.

But the California bill allows ISPs to exempt entire categories of Internet content (such as video and music) from data caps. That means the zero-rating in programs like T-Mobile’s Binge On and Music Freedom would be allowed under the pending California law.

Ajit Pai calls California’s net neutrality rules “illegal” [Jon Brodkin/Ars Technica]

In the years during which the new EU Copyright Directive was being drafted, a variety of proposals were considered and rejected by the EU’s own experts, and purged from the draft text, but two of these proposals were reintroduced, slipped back into the Directive on the day the GDPR came into effect, while everyone’s attention […]


The New Yorker invited white supremacist sponge Steve Bannon to headline its festival. The magazine is famous for its cartoons’ caption competitions, but it was discovered not so long ago that the phrase “Christ, what an asshole” perfectly captions all of them. I propose that editor David Remnick’s excuse for inviting Bannon — “I have […]


Yesterday, the FCC published an admission that it had lied about a supposed hack-attack that it blamed for the collapse of its public comments portal that led to the agency eventually shutting down public comment and announcing that it would give equal weight to obviously forged anti-Net Neutrality comments and the pro-Neutrality comments it received.


There’s no shortage of apps available for your Mac, and, while it’s great to have options, this overabundance makes it difficult to find the apps worth installing on your computer. Thankfully, there’s the Pay What You Want: The Ultimate Mac Bundle ft. 2Do to simplify the process, which boasts 10 of the best Mac apps out […]


Sleek, minimalist, and convenient, Apple’s AirPods are a popular pick for those looking to upgrade to Bluetooth audio, but not everyone can afford the hefty $160 price tag. Whether you’re on a budget or just want something a little different, we’ve rounded up four pieces of audio gear that make for convenient Bluetooth listening, and […]


Our tech collections are growing, and with most of us packing more than just our smartphone in our everyday carry, keeping your devices energized when you’re out and about isn’t easy. Therein lies the value of this PowerUP 11,000mAh Triple USB Battery, which can power up to three devices on the go. Boasting a massive 11,000mAh capacity, […]